A grade on this site is built from what a trader actually buys into: the contract, the published rules and the price, each read firsthand from the firm’s own pages. The sections below show how that evidence turns into one letter, and what we will not let it turn into.
What the grade weighs
One letter per firm, set by our own review of the published evidence, never by the firm. Six factors carry the grade, and their weights are fixed in advance so no single result can be argued into a better letter after the fact. What each letter means, and the score it takes to reach it, is set out on the A+ to F scale.
| Factor | Weight | What moves it |
|---|---|---|
| Payout reliability | 25% | Whether the money arrived, how long it took, and whether the transaction is independently checkable. Scored today on the payout evidence a firm has: a payout summary it reports about itself, such as a total paid out or a payout statistic, scores 70; its own list of individual payouts 75; payments we have matched to a record outside the firm 80, or 85 for five or more, and up to 100 as we match more payments. The grading scale lists every level. Ratings and testimonials never count. Without such evidence, a grade can reach B+ at most, unless its score is 95 or more. |
| Rule fairness | 20% | What the contract lets the firm do to a trader who keeps to the published rules, such as take back earned profit, end the account or change the rules after purchase. A clause costs points only when it puts a trader’s money, account, remedy or rights at stake. |
| Trading conditions | 20% | Six parts, scored on the firm’s typical account, out of 20: drawdown type 5, drawdown size against the profit target 5, daily loss limit 3, consistency rule 3, restrictions on news, overnight holds, automated trading and copy trading 2, and platforms 2. Execution, spreads and fills are not scored yet. |
| Company trust | 15% | What the contract says about who you deal with and what happens when something goes wrong: the governing law, the forum a dispute is heard in, and any term that penalizes a trader for contesting a decision. A missing headquarters country or founding year costs nothing on its own. |
| Challenge value | 15% | The true effective price after any code, per $1,000 of account size, together with the profit split and scaling you are actually paid under. Scored today: the price only. |
| Support | 5% | How the firm answers under load, and the quality of the answer. The contractual route when a decision is contested is weighed under company trust. |
NR means we have not assessed the firm. It is neither a warning nor an endorsement, and it is not a low grade on the grading scale: it is the absence of one. When desk testing begins, we will buy a challenge, trade it to a payout and time the money to the wallet. We have not completed that test at any firm we cover, and each review lists the published evidence behind its grade and what remains unscored.
Where the grades sit today
This is the live distribution across the catalog, not a target and not a curve. It clusters in the middle, and we would rather publish a letter that says what it is based on than a confident guess.
45 firms are in the catalog today. 45 of these grades are preliminary: the letters can move as verification of the records completes.
- Grade A 0 (0%)
- Grade B 42 (93%)
- Grade C 3 (7%)
- Grade D 0 (0%)
- Grade F 0 (0%)
- Grade NR 0 (0%)
How we treat evidence
Every fact we publish carries an evidence tier and a last-checked date. The tiers are a brightness ladder, not a color scale: a claim does not become true because it is printed in a brighter color, and a lower tier is a statement about our confidence, not an accusation.
- Verified 0 records
- Seen on an account bought with our own money, with the artifact on file. Reserved for a completed desk test.
- Reported 249 records
- Published by the firm in its own terms, help center or pricing page, and re-read on every release.
- Claimed 0 records
- Asserted in marketing with no contractual source behind it. Recorded, never used to lift a grade.
- Refused 0 records
- We asked and the firm would not answer. Silence is a fact about a firm, so we publish it.
What money cannot buy
- When desk testing begins, challenges will be bought with desk funds. We do not accept comped accounts, and no firm will be able to tell which account is ours.
- Commissions never touch the rubric, a score, or the order of a toplist. The weights are set before any firm is graded.
- Downgrades publish immediately, partners included, and the change is logged on the firm’s review under Review history.
- No firm sees a grade before it is public, and no firm can request a re-score outside the normal monthly re-check.
How a grade is re-checked
Every graded firm is re-checked once a month, starting 23 October 2026. A re-check re-reads the published terms and re-prices every account size. Payout tests have not started yet. Once they do, a re-check will also repeat a payout test whose result is older than the cycle. If a rule changed, the change is dated and the affected facts are re-tiered.
When we get it wrong
Write to corrections@propfirmgrade.com. We correct within 48 hours and log every change under Review history on the firm’s page, including what the page said before.
PropFirmGrade earns a commission when you buy through links on this site, at no cost to you. Grades are editorial and independent; commissions never change a grade or a rank.