Explore PropFirmGrade

Methodology changelog

Every revision to the grading method, dated, with what changed and why. A grade means little if the rubric moves silently underneath it, so each change is kept here in full rather than folded quietly into the next version of the page that describes it.

2026

24 October: more payout evidence counts, and matched payments can score up to 100

We re-read the payout evidence firms publish, and matched more payments ourselves, on 24 October 2026. Most grades that moved went up; one went down, where a payout score counted for the first time and sat below the firm’s other scores.

  • Dated payouts a firm posts on its own official accounts count as its own payout list, the same as a list on its website.
  • Matched payments can now score above 85. Eight, twelve or twenty payments we matched to a record outside the firm, reaching at least two, three or four different recipients, score 90, 95 or 100.
  • Where a firm pays through Rise and recipients cannot be seen, those levels need the same number of matched payouts from the firm’s own list, spread across several transactions and days. That counts repeated evidence, not different recipients.
  • An unpublished funded-trader agreement costs one small amount, the same at every firm, until we hold and read it.
  • A score of 95 or more is an A+ with or without payout evidence. Below that, a firm without payout evidence still cannot go above B+.

23 October: contract terms cost points but no longer cap a grade

We regraded every firm on 23 October 2026, and the payout evidence levels below were set on 24 October. No firm’s grade went down.

  • A contract term no longer caps a letter. Terms that let a firm take back money you have earned, or punish criticism, still cost points in rule fairness or company trust, and every review still shows them. They no longer hold a letter below what its score earns.
  • A clause costs points only when its wording does harm. It has to put a trader’s money, account, remedy or rights at stake when the trader keeps to the published rules. Each clause that fails that test is listed with its reason and costs nothing.
  • Payout evidence is scored in levels. A payout summary a firm reports about itself, such as a total paid out or a payout statistic, scores 70, its own list of individual payouts 75, and payments we have matched to a record outside the firm 80, or 85 for five or more. Ratings and testimonials never count. A firm with no such evidence still cannot go above B+.
  • Missing company details cost nothing on their own. A headquarters country or founding year the firm does not publish no longer takes points off company trust.
  • A bare class-action waiver costs less than one that comes with further limits on how you can bring a claim.

15 October: improvements to our grading method

We improved how we grade firms, reviewed with Krishi Chowdhary, our external grading expert. Every grade on the site now uses the improved method, and each review explains its grade factor by factor.

  • Evidence that a firm pays now counts. Until a firm has that evidence, it cannot reach our top grades.
  • Trading conditions weigh the rules that decide whether you pass or fail: the drawdown and how it compares with the profit target, the daily loss limit, any consistency rule, trading restrictions and platforms.
  • Findings from our full read of each firm’s contract now count toward its grade.
  • Prices reflect what you would pay today: any live discount code, the account’s own currency converted to US dollars, and any activation fee.
  • Firms that sell in several markets are graded across the markets we can score.
  • Some contract terms limit a grade whatever its score, such as a term that lets a firm take back money you have earned.

9 October: contract wording alone no longer takes a grade below C-

From 9 October 2026, the wording of a firm’s contract can take its grade down to C- and no further. A D or an F now needs evidence of how a firm has treated traders in practice, such as payouts refused, disputes left unresolved or signs of fraud.

8 October: a rule on some accounts counts less than a rule on all of them

A rule that appears in only some of a firm’s accounts now weighs less in its grade than a rule that applies to everything it sells. Seven firms’ scores moved slightly; no published grade changed. Separately, the same day, Blue Guardian moved from B+ to B because of a new finding on its Instant Starter account.

25 September: what the grade is based on

On 22 September 2026, we settled on one published explanation of the grade’s basis: the firm’s contracts, published rules and prices, read firsthand, without a payout test. Before this, our pages described the grade as computed from part of the rubric. Only the published wording changed, and no letter moved.

16 September: the cut points are ratified

The cut points that turn a score out of 100 into a letter were ratified on 16 September 2026. The table sets out the score each letter starts from, and the score below which a firm receives an F.

LetterScoreRatified
A+From 9516 September 2026
AFrom 8716 September 2026
A-From 7916 September 2026
B+From 7716 September 2026
BFrom 7416 September 2026
B-From 7316 September 2026
C+From 6716 September 2026
CFrom 5716 September 2026
C-From 5116 September 2026
D+From 4516 September 2026
DFrom 3616 September 2026
D-From 2716 September 2026
FBelow 2716 September 2026

They were set against the real distribution of all 36 scored firms rather than guessed in advance, and setting them moved no published letter. The full ladder is set out in the letter grading scale.

1 September: the six weights are settled

The rubric weights were ratified by Krishi Chowdhary, the external grading expert, and recorded as ruling R12. Payout reliability 25, rule fairness 20, trading conditions 20, company trust 15, challenge value 15, support and disputes 5.

Two of those moved. Trading conditions rose from 15 to 20, split ten to drawdown and ten to platform quality. The reasoning was not that the drawdown model matters less: drawdown already carries a separate recognition through rule fairness at 20, so weighting it twice as heavily again inside trading conditions would score one property twice. Execution quality was judged to carry economic weight of its own, because poor spreads and fills widen every loss and clip every win.

Support and disputes fell from 10 to 5, with contract-level dispute machinery scoring under company trust instead. Those are one decision rather than two. Fifty-seven of the 170 contract findings across the firms we cover are dispute or remedy machinery, and seven of those are critical. Halving support and disputes would have halved the weight of a third of the evidence, had it been scored there. It belongs to the question a trader is actually asking, which is whether a firm will seize on a term to avoid paying. Support and disputes at 5 is responsiveness and ticket quality only.

Nothing had been scored when the decision was taken. The change cost no rescoring and corrected no published grade.

Search PropFirmGrade

We may earn a commission through our links. Firms cannot buy our grades or placement.